{"reviews":[{"review_id":"SITE-AUTHOR-REVIEW1","scope":"PUBLIC_SITE_ACCESS_AND_EVIDENCE_SYSTEM_ONLY","outcome":"SITE_PUBLIC_AND_EXACT_GLB_BYTES_VERIFIED; LIVE_WEBGL_PLAYBACK_NOT_VERIFIED; ART_RIG_MOTION_RUNTIME_UNAPPROVED","report_url":"/reviews/SITE-AUTHOR-REVIEW1.json","evidence_zip_sha256":"40afa2268683a1731672175598a39845d5c29f266b322c9fc0c1ff0c11aa4976","reviewed_exact_sha256":["2119126f5e6f224e2753d0bf5aec8ea978a1fbe01a3d0b1439ede31577c6041e","c73047cab24f0ec61dde738820221f274194b1f2b50a0e4afb2d55ba1d8564b5"],"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"SITE-AUTHOR-REVIEW2","scope":"CURRENT_PUBLIC_SITE_EVIDENCE_SYSTEM_AND_EXACT_058_STATIC_ART_DYNAMIC_MOTION","outcome":"{\"site_publication_records\": \"470_VERSION_RECORDS_PRESENT; 0_PENDING_RECORDED; NOT_470_FINAL_PASSES\", \"site_review_evidence\": \"IMPROVED_AND_058_FIXED_FALLBACK_DIRECTLY_OPENED\", \"site_live_webgl\": \"UNKNOWN_TIMED_OUT_IN_THIS_CLOUD_BROWSER\", \"art\": \"FRONT_IDENTITY_SUBSTANTIALLY_MATCHED; FINAL_ART_ALLOW_NOT_ISSUED\", \"geometry\": \"STATIC_VISIBLE_SILHOUETTE_CONDITIONAL; HIDDEN_TOPOLOGY_UNKNOWN\", \"rig\": \"HOLD_VISIBLE_ANIMATED_HAND_FOREARM_SPIKE_DEFECT\", \"motion_walking\": \"HOLD_VISIBLE_ANIMATED_DEFORMATION\", \"motion_running\": \"HOLD_VISIBLE_ANIMATED_DEFORMATION\", \"runtime\": \"UNKNOWN_NOT_TESTED\", \"number_of_new_final_character_passes\": 0, \"complete_maps\": 0, \"map_target\": 10}","report_url":"/reviews/SITE-AUTHOR-REVIEW2.json","korean_summary_url":"/reviews/SITE-AUTHOR-REVIEW2_KO.md","report_sha256":"ba923a74df7197a953e104696b614b306be0d314464d943df223c7cf341f15c7","reviewed_exact_sha256":["2119126f5e6f224e2753d0bf5aec8ea978a1fbe01a3d0b1439ede31577c6041e"],"independent_review_axes":{"art":{"status":"ART_CONDITIONAL_VISIBLE_FRONT_MATCH; FINAL_APPROVAL_NOT_ISSUED","confirmed_visible":"Distinctive pale updo/leaf, blue/white cape and sleeve scheme, sage wide pants, patterned sash and boot silhouette broadly maintained","noncritical_todo":"Small facial, cloth-seam, bun-leaf detailing cannot be judged at face-pixel fidelity of 1241x518 wide frame; no authored side/rear original supplied","unknown":"Exact side/back against author originals, under-cape hidden surfaces"},"geometry":{"status":"STATIC_VISIBLE_CONDITIONAL; DYNAMIC_MESH_VISUAL_DEFECT_RECORDED","confirmed_visible":"All four source-axis images show a single full figure, both visible legs/boots and generally uninterrupted outline","not_claimed":"No proof of manifold geometry, collision, hidden mesh topology, triangle intersection or skin data correctness from stills"},"rig":{"status":"RIG_HOLD","required_issue_id":"R058-DYN-01","confirmed_pixel_defect":"Hand/forearm-colored stretched wedge/needle-like triangles recur in moving samples on +X at t~0.67 s for both Walking and Running; +Z also reveals hip-level skin streaks","root_cause":"UNKNOWN; possible skin weight, mesh or joint-transform influence is an INFERENCE only","true_3d_penetration":"UNKNOWN; screen-space overlap of spikes and upper trousers is confirmed, mesh-space crossing not computed","static_skin_structure":"PRESENT_1_SKIN_66_JOINTS_NOT_QUALITY_PASS"},"motion":{"status":"WALKING_HOLD_AND_RUNNING_HOLD","confirmed":"Alternating legs and swinging arms occur over samples, with recurring nonphysical stretch; two clips and six direction files are genuine decoded VP9 video","distinct_running_speed_from_world_motion":"UNKNOWN; differing GLB cycle length is not proof of locomotion quality","foot_sliding":"UNKNOWN_NO_GROUND_OR_FOOT_ROOT_TRACE","contact_and_big_penetration":"UNKNOWN_PHYSICAL_3D_PENETRATION_DESPITE_SCREEN_SPACE_SPIKES","missing_actions":["Idle","Turn","Main-action"]},"runtime":{"status":"NOT_TESTED_UNKNOWN","missing":["Godot 4.7.2 gameplay capture with build/source hash","Live control-to-animation outcome","Collision/nav/foot-lock traces","Mobile FPS and memory measurements"]}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false,"summary_ko":"058 최종: 전면 정체성은 부분 일치. 팔·손의 비정상 삼각형 늘어짐으로 리깅과 걷기·달리기 HOLD. +X 약0.67초에서 재현하며 원인은 아직 미확정입니다."},{"review_id":"A058-SKIN-ROOTCAUSE1","scope":"058 existing GLB and +X Walking/Running at around 0.67s only; separate from 048 review, do not repeat SITE-AUTHOR-REVIEW2","report_url":"/reviews/A058-SKIN-ROOTCAUSE1.json","report_sha256":"57a678cc11c0c26aa80c1002c2669b19ab5ed3db1e4b3b99c5a43f930128be7b","korean_summary_url":"/reviews/DIAGNOSIS048_KO_SUMMARY.md","reviewed_exact_sha256":["2119126f5e6f224e2753d0bf5aec8ea978a1fbe01a3d0b1439ede31577c6041e"],"independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"RIG_HOLD","root_cause":"CONFIRMED_SOURCE_HAND_THIGH_WEIGHT_ASSIGNMENT_FAULT; viewer behavior UNKNOWN"},"motion":{"status":"WALKING_AND_RUNNING_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"UNKNOWN_NOT_TESTED"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false,"summary_ko":"058 손 부위의 허벅지 가중치 결함 확인. 원본 HOLD 유지, 정확 후보 수정 명세 후속 요청 중."},{"review_id":"CHAR048-AUTHOR-REVIEW1","scope":"Only Khasira #048. All four fixed direction PNGs and all six original WebM clips opened/decoded; structure extracted from exact original GLB. Does not re-review #058 or perform any repair.","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR048-AUTHOR-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"b161d6d7803e50d4fd0db54875a0ed29ddc4c08a764401960dcb5518a507e3b3","korean_summary_url":"/reviews/DIAGNOSIS048_KO_SUMMARY.md","reviewed_exact_sha256":["2a30dc49299aa88bd9ba410a816eb2145fb7c67e4b134b0ae6a584cecf22b764"],"independent_review_axes":{"art":{"status":"VISIBLE_FRONT_IDENTITY_ART_ALLOW_SCOPE_ONLY","final_character_art_status":"CONDITIONAL_UNTIL_AUTHOR_SIDE_BACK_AND_HIGH_DETAIL","evidence":["official FRONT pixels viewed","4 original-axis static pixels viewed","matching cream/yellow/black utility outfit and warm ponytail/headband"],"mandatory_art_repair":"NONE_FROM_CURRENT_PIXELS","nonfatal_todo":["micro-face likeness and fine belt/buckle print need close 3D still","back/side original author reference missing"],"hidden_unknown":true},"geometry":{"status":"VISIBLE_SILHOUETTE_ALLOW_ONLY","mandatory_visible_geometry_issue":"NONE_OBSERVED","hidden_topology_manifold_true_collision":"UNKNOWN","do_not_infer_from_TRI_count":true},"rig":{"status":"VISIBLE_ANIMATED_CONDITIONAL_NOT_FULL_PASS","mandatory_visible_large_spike":"NONE_OBSERVED_048","structural_presence":"66 joints + skin + IBM checked; 3 JOINTS/WEIGHTS sets; not auto-rig PASS","local_finger_weight_risk":"Small CPU edge stretch hotspots exist, not visually proven fatal; do not auto-repaint","Godot_vs_browser":"UNKNOWN_UNTESTED"},"motion":{"status":"WALKING_AND_RUNNING_VISIBLE_CONDITIONAL_NOT_FULL_PASS","clipped_gross_hand_or_leg_spikes":"NONE_OBSERVED","action_semantic_weak_distinction":"추정_NONFATAL_TODO","true_speed_root_motion_foot_lock":"UNKNOWN"},"runtime":{"status":"UNKNOWN_NOT_TESTED","missing":["Godot 4.7.2 actual gameplay, camera and SHA receipt","Idle/Turn/Main-action video or test","measured stance/contact/foot sliding in game","collision/navmesh/mobile CPU-GPU FPS/memory","source author side/back and weight-paint record"]}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false,"summary_ko":"048 가시 정체성·실루엣 허용 범위, 리깅·걷기·달리기는 조건부, 게임 미검증. 즉시 필수 대형 시각결함 없음; 다음 캐릭터 검수 가능."},{"review_id":"058-CANDIDATE2-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/058-CANDIDATE2-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"e60d055b445d58bd0713622f5ea93ed10093ff364ddaad43b60fec8d39352198","reviewed_exact_sha256":["c5dd610fe74fb18a3b45562b7e4dc25e12883f20586d460829e64b76026af737"],"independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"HOLD"},"motion":{"status":"WALKING_RUNNING_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"UNKNOWN_NOT_TESTED"}},"summary_ko":"058 후보2 실제 A/B 잔여 변형으로 HOLD. 후보3 별도 생성·검수 중.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR068-AUTHOR-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR068-AUTHOR-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"5a3e8dd10df9d02cebdca202941ee6019ff2644aa3b52c0a85351224dcad1fe7","reviewed_exact_sha256":["1c44073e5a04949c21ff8a152c71db4a9f7e38e3907928f3be025ccf832e95e4"],"independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"HOLD"},"motion":{"status":"WALKING_RUNNING_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"UNKNOWN_NOT_TESTED"}},"summary_ko":"068 가시 정체성 조건부. 실제 스킨 결함과 걷기·달리기 변형으로 리깅·모션 HOLD.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"058-CANDIDATE3-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/058-CANDIDATE3-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"7cb62b5ea35fc1b9c3b652f9cf9dd12f9cba2f67371f5de2ffc239cfda38c893","reviewed_exact_sha256":["37b7905432c1b35cc3bfc9d213fc026136b2b67cbf7e8b9cb91d06d7a53ea85d"],"independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"HOLD_PENDING_RESIDUAL_LOCAL_EVIDENCE"},"motion":{"status":"MAJOR_WEDGE_RESOLVED_FULL_APPROVAL_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"NATIVE_PLAYBACK_OBSERVED_GAMEPLAY_UNKNOWN"}},"summary_ko":"058 후보3 큰 팔·손→허리 쐐기 해소를 원제작 GPT 확인. 손목 경계2정점과Running2면의 실제 노출 확인이 남아 전체 HOLD.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"058-CANDIDATE3-EXACT-RESIDUAL-ROI-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/058-CANDIDATE3-EXACT-RESIDUAL-ROI-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"c0220aabd5a963e35468c75e560f89b6d10ca4157281c930d641e7980cae309d","reviewed_exact_sha256":["37b7905432c1b35cc3bfc9d213fc026136b2b67cbf7e8b9cb91d06d7a53ea85d"],"independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"HOLD_RESIDUAL_VISIBLE_SKIN_DEFECTS"},"motion":{"status":"WALKING_RUNNING_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_UNKNOWN"}},"summary_ko":"후보3 큰 쐐기 개선 유지. 손목·소매 잔여 변형은 실제 결함 확인. 정확 면 귀속과 수정 목표값 미확정으로 추가패치 HOLD.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"058-CANDIDATE4-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/058-CANDIDATE4-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"52aedeaf0f86541526136df9acedd55f66701f818ec171634feb6d3bdbc0c5a8","reviewed_exact_sha256":["a71a3ce057f5f85e54d974029e5834ebba1dd4bdca420693ccabb29ca9ab4dc3"],"summary_ko":"058 후보4 손목·전완 국소 보완 통과. 6영상 표본에서 큰 새 결함 미관찰. 전체 리깅·모션 HOLD, 브라우저 교차검사·게임 미검증.","independent_review_axes":{"geometry":{"status":"ORIGINAL_ATTRIBUTES_PRESERVED"},"rig":{"status":"LOCAL_SIX_POSE_PASS;GLOBAL_HOLD"},"motion":{"status":"NATIVE_SIX_VIEW_CONDITIONAL;GLOBAL_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-AUTHOR-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-AUTHOR-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"19397b8f403ea96a9fa1f9b6377a6c4b251b2a641394bf399e3f2fd335bbb525","reviewed_exact_sha256":["049980cd3af05484a47c8f738784395047ea83dd5e51b70044a59bc4704a6d85"],"summary_ko":"073 정지 외형 조건부. 다리·발 긴 검은 면의 가시 동작 결함으로 geometry·rig·motion HOLD. 수정 전 정확 face-ID 필요.","independent_review_axes":{"art":{"status":"STATIC_CONDITIONAL"},"geometry":{"status":"DYNAMIC_HOLD"},"rig":{"status":"HOLD"},"motion":{"status":"WALKING_RUNNING_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR074-AUTHOR-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR074-AUTHOR-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"316b6dd340112f4da485e0688dba42d61cb101571763f0bb62032f12fd3a23d5","reviewed_exact_sha256":["8d68900347671b590261409b598a8452c85f4a783060357402f8efecfc635a2b"],"summary_ko":"074 제출 가시 범위 주요 미술 정체성 ART_ALLOW. Geometry·걷기·달리기 조건부,rig HOLD. 국소 수치 이상은 가시 결함 미확정이며 패치 승인0. Godot·게임·모바일·보조물리 별도 미검증.","independent_review_axes":{"art":{"status":"ART_ALLOW_SUBMITTED_VISIBLE_SCOPE"},"geometry":{"status":"CONDITIONAL"},"rig":{"status":"HOLD_IMPORT_LOCAL_VISIBILITY_GATE"},"motion":{"status":"WALKING_RUNNING_CONDITIONAL"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"073-EXACT-FOUR-POSE-VISIBLE-FACE-ID1-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/073-EXACT-FOUR-POSE-VISIBLE-FACE-ID1-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"54bde9d3a557b701562b36da045d6f6db00a7c2650bdbb679c099683532a045b","reviewed_exact_sha256":["049980cd3af05484a47c8f738784395047ea83dd5e51b70044a59bc4704a6d85"],"summary_ko":"073 발 보조본이 전완 아래 연결된 원인 확정. 원저자 별도후보1 부모2개·정적키 수정 계약 수령. 실제 후보 A/B 재검수 전,손·허리 별도 HOLD.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"ORIGINAL_HOLD_EXACT_FOOT_AUX_PARENT_CANDIDATE_CONTRACT"},"motion":{"status":"HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"058-CANDIDATE4-BROWSER-LOCAL-GATE1","report_url":"/reviews/058-CANDIDATE4-BROWSER-LOCAL-GATE1.json","report_sha256":"0be2adbcb9fafc07404adffb47ce89d404a47c42bbef2c04dbae1ae08686419b","reviewed_exact_sha256":["a71a3ce057f5f85e54d974029e5834ebba1dd4bdca420693ccabb29ca9ab4dc3"],"summary_ko":"058 후보4 +X 브라우저 걷기·달리기 312프레임 국소 gate 통과. 전체 rig·motion HOLD와게임·모바일·보조물리UNKNOWN 유지.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LOCAL_BROWSER_GATE_PASS_GLOBAL_HOLD"},"motion":{"status":"LOCAL_PLUSX_CONDITIONAL_PASS_GLOBAL_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-FOOT-PARENT-CANDIDATE1-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-FOOT-PARENT-CANDIDATE1-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"f49bc3daccf2add86d78e8a7a66a16ce44a19e1748566e0f1d1cad1c0a3630c3","reviewed_exact_sha256":["ab315fb2b630038431464955bb1f4a2d8429db022906173e5c0a1765cacf1a49"],"summary_ko":"073 후보1 발 보조본 부모 수정은4정확포즈·6원본/후보3축 영상에서 국소 시각 통과. 추가 발 패치 불필요. 손·허리 잔여결함으로 전체 rig·motion HOLD;브라우저·게임·모바일·보조물리UNKNOWN.","independent_review_axes":{"geometry":{"status":"FOOT_VISIBLE_LOCAL_PASS_WHOLE_HOLD"},"rig":{"status":"FOOT_LOCAL_NATIVE_PASS_GLOBAL_HOLD"},"motion":{"status":"FOOT_WALK_RUN_3AXIS_LOCAL_PASS_GLOBAL_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_BROWSER_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR074-NATIVE-SOURCEFACE-GATE1-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR074-NATIVE-SOURCEFACE-GATE1-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"28837e730864206a0093973de3eddea7315892b08b9b9da4e04886f45008a5e5","reviewed_exact_sha256":["8d68900347671b590261409b598a8452c85f4a783060357402f8efecfc635a2b"],"summary_ko":"074 지정4포즈 실제 원재질·면노출 검수에서 명확한 파열·돌출 미확인:국소 NO_PATCH.대상8정점 양수영향 누락0,전체161정점 수치TODO·리깅HOLD 유지.4개native동작 표본 조건부;실제게임·모바일·보조물리UNKNOWN.","independent_review_axes":{"art":{"status":"PRIOR_ART_ALLOW_VISIBLE_SCOPE_PRESERVED"},"geometry":{"status":"LOCAL_NO_CONFIRMED_TEAR_GLOBAL_CONDITIONAL"},"rig":{"status":"TARGET8_IMPORT_GATE_RESOLVED_NO_PATCH_GLOBAL_HOLD"},"motion":{"status":"NATIVE_4CLIP_SAMPLES_CONDITIONAL"},"runtime":{"status":"IMPORT_PLAYBACK_OBSERVED_GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M080-NATIVE-PBR-PARTIAL1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M080-NATIVE-PBR-PARTIAL1-review.json","report_sha256":"9cce63b8e6b518225fdffea90e43eceb4f4ca22d6bf5898f013e137ddbbf50e9","reviewed_exact_sha256":["e098b640f37bada004f54addbd0a25b0b106f9f3ebf6eea3ab918394294aa3ae","c331f34a62584c6aa9267c94f131952c63e635c96e754a0204ee0c9d903721a4"],"summary_ko":"북풍설인 원저자 두 정확자세 국소검수:명백한 스킨변형 미확인/패치0. 조명민감성 관찰,현재게임 R0/R1미확인·전체HOLD 유지.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-HAND-REST-ATTRIBUTION1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-HAND-REST-ATTRIBUTION1.json","report_sha256":"52cabd1d05db114a106617e53b2c2da376409262ef4be6a18e5213243c54fe41","reviewed_exact_sha256":["ab315fb2b630038431464955bb1f4a2d8429db022906173e5c0a1765cacf1a49"],"summary_ko":"073 오른손중지 계열 허벅지 혼합가중치 원저자 원인확정.85정점 WEIGHTS_0 후보2 exact명세 적용,예상SHA 일치.실제A/B에서 큰 손·허리 각진면 잔여 관찰:원저자 후보재검수 전 HOLD.기존발 국소PASS 유지.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"EXACT_LOCAL_HAND_CANDIDATE_CONTRACT_RECEIVED_ACTUAL_AB_HOLD"},"motion":{"status":"HAND_WAIST_RESIDUAL_VISIBLE_AUTHOR_REVIEW_PENDING"},"runtime":{"status":"NATIVE_CANDIDATE_PLAYBACK_OBSERVED_GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M081-V2-EXISTING-RIG-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M081-V2-EXISTING-RIG-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"2980db6b7e4089dcd5d94296dfa607daf2b9f11d9e45d2f58362a49c5e878590","reviewed_exact_sha256":["81bb51a69ba9fa4b5b7d10e34d5cdc90a81c5fdc1db51e1e2b72efe211b1ae6e","68d3eed88ac42fea55b51b914df8468c64b4742aff5a0df16fe03710f1a385e8"],"summary_ko":"M081 실제v2 녹동문턱식귀:갑판외곽후보의 팔/Head가중치 혼입과 Head기준 비강체 소스변형 수치 확인.정확갑판귀속/native 확인전 패치0·전체HOLD.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-HAND-CANDIDATE2-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-HAND-CANDIDATE2-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"95ffb8ded8b623edae9d8adb648b7731e795b262a93e17f8c72052963f78b1b5","reviewed_exact_sha256":["c7584b1f4ce12e82eb89c7dda6f35ad9463e999c3502922dc012236cf93ca7f4"],"summary_ko":"073 손 후보2 실제국소FAIL·전체HOLD 원저자확정.면/UV경계 누락 원인에242정점 후보3 정확명세 수령·적용.후보3 실제A/B와잔여면 증거 확보;원저자 재검수 전 미승인.발 국소PASS 보존.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"CANDIDATE2_HAND_LOCAL_FAIL_CANDIDATE3_ACTUAL_AUTHOR_REVIEW_PENDING"},"motion":{"status":"WALKING_RUNNING_WHOLE_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"NATIVE_PLAYBACK_OBSERVED_GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M081-WALK-HEADPLATE-NATIVE-PROBE1-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M081-WALK-HEADPLATE-NATIVE-PROBE1-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"571a3ae77090810534058be7aa5ee73c38321159639b493a7d3bc698c0661f98","reviewed_exact_sha256":["81bb51a69ba9fa4b5b7d10e34d5cdc90a81c5fdc1db51e1e2b72efe211b1ae6e"],"summary_ko":"M081원본native126frame60fps·양시점·8weights/index대응 기술통과.표본갑판외곽정점Head기준최대.134658/.126180변위;정확전체갑판sourceface귀속없어패치0·전체HOLD.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M081-HEADPLATE-SEMANTIC-SOURCEFACE-OWNERSHIP1-PARTIAL","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M081-HEADPLATE-SEMANTIC-SOURCEFACE-OWNERSHIP1-PARTIAL.json","report_sha256":"172e314fba9384d3169e6d2ebb6b6d0917689c63e412854124306809d59a66b8","reviewed_exact_sha256":["81bb51a69ba9fa4b5b7d10e34d5cdc90a81c5fdc1db51e1e2b72efe211b1ae6e"],"summary_ko":"M081원제작갑판부분귀속4261faces/5767verts(표본80/449포함)실수령.10component와원본면/정점·crosspart shared/seam0독립대조일치.전체mask미완성/미인증25822faces수정금지·패치0.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M081-HEADPLATE-INNER-JUNCTION-FACE-LABEL1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M081-HEADPLATE-INNER-JUNCTION-FACE-LABEL1.json","report_sha256":"bf2f21574ee6f9d8103c23b980eaedbb931758d5a3d39f2862f0793cb294e298","reviewed_exact_sha256":["81bb51a69ba9fa4b5b7d10e34d5cdc90a81c5fdc1db51e1e2b72efe211b1ae6e"],"summary_ko":"M081 신규3261면 부위귀속과8751면정확미결목록 실수령·원본index독립검증.기존4261보존,갑판부분5890면.전체mask/weights패치미승인·경계HOLD.새판별근거전동일요청반복금지.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-HAND-CANDIDATE3-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-HAND-CANDIDATE3-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"2fac4980fe9c0096a873f2abbc9be542b51ba2549af6b143a9518f797c56d883","reviewed_exact_sha256":["373f056f0b4f43ca5fce58da2ddcd9a162fce78e528a3c4cc5153738dc0c1d94"],"summary_ko":"073 후보3 원저자검수:기존중지4면 수치국소개선,오른엄지 잔여와왼손별도HOLD.후보4 정확35정점 엄지기술수정·실제4포즈6영상확보,시각재검수전 전체HOLD.발국소PASS보존.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"OLD_MIDDLE_NUMERIC_LOCAL_IMPROVED_RIGHTTHUMB_FAIL_LEFTAUX_HOLD_NEW_CANDIDATE_UNREVIEWED"},"motion":{"status":"WALKING_RUNNING_WHOLE_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"NATIVE_PLAYBACK_OBSERVED_GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M082-V2-RING-WALKING-EXISTING-RIG-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M082-V2-RING-WALKING-EXISTING-RIG-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"e45d3a22348fefe468d1ea7e25bcc2a5ed6464a62830f6d93e718688baa7bce1","reviewed_exact_sha256":["70ed2c3d8144b5866c6c7dd29dec9d500e26e613a8c6ecc68eac74f815e32a25"],"summary_ko":"M082v2공심환5정지자세 국소허용·고리완전강체불필요.고리변형/부착전체HOLD,patchnull.원저자nativegate에70frame60fps동기영상과전체sourceindex/8weights대응확보;고리landmark미인증으로수치PASS없음.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-RIGHTTHUMB-CANDIDATE4-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-RIGHTTHUMB-CANDIDATE4-ACTUAL-AB-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"d86038598a086b9cba5c851958b6087f83d469889bd8321f64c0654f5fd42e19","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 후보4 정확35정점 엄지패치 적용무결성PASS·실제엄지시각HOLD.원저자요청 한Running포즈 전신/실제근접 면ID와GPU35정점42면 추가증거 준비.발국소PASS·왼손/전체HOLD 보존.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"PATCH_INTEGRITY_PASS_RIGHTTHUMB_VISUAL_HOLD_ONE_FACE_GATE_REQUIRED"},"motion":{"status":"GLOBAL_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-C4-RIGHTTHUMB-MINIMUM-FACE-GATE1-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-C4-RIGHTTHUMB-MINIMUM-FACE-GATE1-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"afbefe4410bac653025f226378b545b33e58cae1f4784cfeda0bfa01bc0bde5b","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 후보4 오른엄지35정점·관련42면 Running0.0527778/+X75 지정포즈 국소PASS.다른오른손·전완/왼손/허리/전체모션HOLD;게임·모바일·보조물리UNKNOWN.추가패치없음.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"RIGHT_THUMB35_LOCAL_PASS_ONE_RUNNING_X_POSE_ONLY_GLOBAL_HOLD"},"motion":{"status":"FULLCLIPS_OTHERAXES_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M082-NATIVE-RING-LANDMARK-OWNERSHIP1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M082-NATIVE-RING-LANDMARK-OWNERSHIP1.json","report_sha256":"de2b85d3b1f603b3d8f5556e1fccd69aa7067231b6ec86e767ed753d289d1fbe","reviewed_exact_sha256":["70ed2c3d8144b5866c6c7dd29dec9d500e26e613a8c6ecc68eac74f815e32a25"],"summary_ko":"M082 exact원화SHA해소·source16표본귀속수령(6국소고리/6미확정/4부착관찰),전체mask·patch미승인.원본face/XYZ/UV/joint8weights일치독립검증.3bone5시각보완후상체상대수치계산;품질은재검수대기.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M082-RING-LOCAL-NUMERIC-VERDICT1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M082-RING-LOCAL-NUMERIC-VERDICT1.json","report_sha256":"3dcd6e9d1f0868bceeba4d2450058e4fe63bf2dc369bebed6778c7cb6190030d","reviewed_exact_sha256":["70ed2c3d8144b5866c6c7dd29dec9d500e26e613a8c6ecc68eac74f815e32a25"],"summary_ko":"M082 고리확정6점·5exacttime·기존native영상 국소조건부허용.전체고리·접합부·game/mobile/physics/공격HOLD,patchnull.새특정결함증거전동일16점/영상반복금지;독립M087진행.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M087-V2-TRIPLATE-EXISTING-MOVE-ATTACK-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M087-V2-TRIPLATE-EXISTING-MOVE-ATTACK-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"48d9e6d1b8224c3b4cfafa1ac68fcd94117663dcd0162287a5288fb7a3525c9e","reviewed_exact_sha256":["b59f967f599e7ef67b2f9bd9febf76f372bc2a309247434c2d04c63f8f9f7711","ea3b110bc3a2038e6e1f3465805bf9c160e3abbf929c564af0f77e30b269ac96"],"summary_ko":"M087v2 3판몸통기울기국소허용·Move읽힘/공격지지위험native검증요구.45본4weights원본+기존라이브러리181frame실재생확보,공격발주변점y위아래큰변위.정확발바닥/판부착전체UNKNOWN·원제작재검수전패치0.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-LEFTAUX-TRUE-REST-SEMANTIC1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-LEFTAUX-TRUE-REST-SEMANTIC1.json","report_sha256":"0be41dcf1cb546cc5a80a229f1af4eea42f3a590408ad083f86af6d8539e336f","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 후보4 왼손34면 의미구분HOLD·패치없음.기존REST카메라2면번호지도와픽셀근거보완.오른엄지35정점지정포즈국소PASS유지;전체모션·게임·모바일UNKNOWN.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LEFT34_SEMANTIC_HOLD_NO_PATCH_THUMB35_SCOPED_PASS_PRESERVED"},"motion":{"status":"FULLCLIPS_OTHERAXES_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M087-NATIVE-SUPPORT-ROOTCAUSE1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M087-NATIVE-SUPPORT-ROOTCAUSE1.json","report_sha256":"260121d642b0be12447120a1554672e918ce14342a3bf59bd9be3cdfad6324ee","reviewed_exact_sha256":["b59f967f599e7ef67b2f9bd9febf76f372bc2a309247434c2d04c63f8f9f7711","ea3b110bc3a2038e6e1f3465805bf9c160e3abbf929c564af0f77e30b269ac96"],"summary_ko":"M087기존Attack full.56/.78/.96및postcommit.24지지동작REVISE확정(진단바닥관통).Bone001이44조상으로다리영향경로확인.원본rig전역FAIL아님·판국소허용유지.정확4sole+pivot/3platebase부위귀속없어patchnull.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-LEFTAUX-REST-FRONTMOST34-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-LEFTAUX-REST-FRONTMOST34-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"44cc5e3a1561a85d3759c4c3b0418c0b24b1b47d9a963749e1d4a85e9953c1bf","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 후보4 왼손22면 의미귀속확인(장갑16·소매장식6),12면HOLD·패치없음.남은12면사선3뷰보완.오른엄지35지정포즈국소PASS유지;동작·게임·모바일HOLD/UNKNOWN.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LEFT22_SEMANTIC_ATTRIBUTION_12_HOLD_NO_PATCH_THUMB35_SCOPED_PASS_PRESERVED"},"motion":{"status":"FULLCLIPS_OTHERAXES_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M087-LOCAL-SUPPORT-PLATE-ROOT-SOURCE-PICK1-PARTIAL","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M087-LOCAL-SUPPORT-PLATE-ROOT-SOURCE-PICK1-PARTIAL.json","report_sha256":"a6ea95fde31f5d07538fab0b560b72a060971de3352356df899009dbee4f00d1","reviewed_exact_sha256":["b59f967f599e7ef67b2f9bd9febf76f372bc2a309247434c2d04c63f8f9f7711"],"summary_ko":"M087네발국소하향면/가지본인증.13표본면/52raw가중치/XYZ/UV/법선/면적/seam독립대조일치.3등판융합접경F17454/F21768/F21068미확정으로patchHOLD·기존AttackREVISE유지.신규판별근거전동일검사반복금지;M073진행.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-LEFTAUX-OBLIQUE12-SEMANTIC-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-LEFTAUX-OBLIQUE12-SEMANTIC-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"24635795061c1400244d9c72264634287e6522abedefd126e69b2f33ea27e393","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 후보4 왼손34면 REST 의미분류완료(장갑21·소매장식13)·스킨패치없음.동적보조본/손본메모리진단6뷰보완.발·오른엄지국소PASS유지;동작원인·게임·모바일HOLD/UNKNOWN.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LEFT34_SEMANTIC_CLASSIFIED_DYNAMIC_OWNERSHIP_HOLD_NO_PATCH_THUMB35_PASS_PRESERVED"},"motion":{"status":"FULLCLIPS_OTHERAXES_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M073-EXISTING-ATTACK-BASELINE-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M073-EXISTING-ATTACK-BASELINE-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"ddf16cdd04885db466db3dc02297afa2985925bd52781acfb30d83dea7baec2c","reviewed_exact_sha256":["3dd2c185b9cbf3166ac2e44ee73ed91b0043a940e2702167bffaba93db10932c","4f44fbc22304b8168cef2b4e7260a3326267430a99fced979dd158447d74fd37"],"summary_ko":"M073기존갈퀴Attack준비·전개·반동읽힘REVISE,리그/skin확정불량없음HOLD.원저자지정native기본자세/걷기0초A-B146frame확보,시작자세사실상동일·연속공격재검수대기.정확패치null.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-LEFTAUX-C4-DYNAMIC-OWNERSHIP-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-LEFTAUX-C4-DYNAMIC-OWNERSHIP-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"ca04b39aedbdf9aabdb2286781e070d82c4a0cc9097910613cfd181a8989472b","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 후보4 왼손Head/Hand 상대이동혼합스킨원인가설강화·최종수정HOLD.34면REST구분완료유지.추가손공간D메모리진단2뷰보완·새GLB없음;전역HOLD.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LEFT34_SEMANTIC_CLASSIFIED_DYNAMIC_OWNERSHIP_HOLD_NO_PATCH_THUMB35_PASS_PRESERVED"},"motion":{"status":"FULLCLIPS_OTHERAXES_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M073-NATIVE-RESTOFFSET-AB-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M073-NATIVE-RESTOFFSET-AB-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"d6ef90a58416c535baaca3fdf65b0b781409e61c5a9d87f22941eef863948552","reviewed_exact_sha256":["3dd2c185b9cbf3166ac2e44ee73ed91b0043a940e2702167bffaba93db10932c","4f44fbc22304b8168cef2b4e7260a3326267430a99fced979dd158447d74fd37"],"summary_ko":"M073직접native146frame A/B검수완료:지정walk0시작자세차이가설기각(32본6시각최대약5.96e-7),기존Attack읽힘REVISE확정.원본RigSkinHOLD·patchnull.실제갈퀴말단/양발sole3점귀속만추가요구,영상/Host반복금지.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-LEFTAUX-C4-HANDSPACE-D-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-LEFTAUX-C4-HANDSPACE-D-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"6ff489c9f64b004b4df6faee71b2d2969201f488ffd88d0eacc5da5a3eb2183b","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 왼손 상대이동 원인 국소지지·전체분기HOLD·패치없음. 새동일조건 A/D24장: 핵심2면 양클립 확인, 주변28면 중25면 식별·3면가림HOLD. 어깨처럼 보이는 부위의 새D돌출 우려 원저자 재검수대기; 발·엄지 국소PASS유지.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LEFT34_SEMANTIC_CLASSIFIED_DYNAMIC_OWNERSHIP_HOLD_NO_PATCH_THUMB35_PASS_PRESERVED"},"motion":{"status":"FULLCLIPS_OTHERAXES_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M073-CLAWTIP-AND-BISOLE-SOURCE-ANCHOR-PICK1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M073-CLAWTIP-AND-BISOLE-SOURCE-ANCHOR-PICK1.json","report_sha256":"3e06ac8860a47fbcf8eef75f469a5b85e4120b2550b7bfa5f4be2f2866682807","reviewed_exact_sha256":["3dd2c185b9cbf3166ac2e44ee73ed91b0043a940e2702167bffaba93db10932c"],"summary_ko":"M073거대갈퀴말단F22381/V16614·좌soleF12340/V14074·우soleF21765/V11842국소인증.원본면/XYZUV/raw4weights/seam독립일치.실제native3정점가중치읽기와기존12pose로CPU궤적계산,전체접지/공격판정미승인·patchnull.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M073-THREE-ANCHOR-TRAJECTORY-REPAIR-DECISION1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M073-THREE-ANCHOR-TRAJECTORY-REPAIR-DECISION1.json","report_sha256":"7aadc660d9388fb4f93908539271efd263967b4b71c2f826d5f56b826797f747","reviewed_exact_sha256":["3dd2c185b9cbf3166ac2e44ee73ed91b0043a940e2702167bffaba93db10932c","4f44fbc22304b8168cef2b4e7260a3326267430a99fced979dd158447d74fd37","78f72dac13eaa006e27325ea3337920233639d7146ca49b423201924502a987e"],"summary_ko":"M073원저자기존4트랙키순서재배치후보2시험허용.정확script/base/afterSHA와4행diff검증,별도후보146frame실재생.갈퀴Z준비→전개→따라감증가·비대상28본local불변,시각최종재검수대기.원본/게임불변·정본미채택.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-C4-HANDSPACE-D-OFFAXIS30-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-C4-HANDSPACE-D-OFFAXIS30-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"15718af34a83d9afb020be70cb55b91fbc0a5d1f9b08e325320d9c21eaa302c3","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 원저자최종:전체AUX26~28손공간이동 REJECT·C4유지·패치없음. 자식27/28만의RAM F10화면 새증거 제출:핵심D대응·기존28회귀면A대응이나 다른늘어짐 잔존·전역HOLD. 발·오른엄지 국소PASS보존.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LEFT34_SEMANTIC_CLASSIFIED_DYNAMIC_OWNERSHIP_HOLD_NO_PATCH_THUMB35_PASS_PRESERVED"},"motion":{"status":"FULLCLIPS_OTHERAXES_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M073-CANDIDATE2-NATIVE-AB-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M073-CANDIDATE2-NATIVE-AB-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"5e982c1985995a525851e12b2c9af77672347ef78cdfa47b3459ed3a4c208ee9","reviewed_exact_sha256":["3dd2c185b9cbf3166ac2e44ee73ed91b0043a940e2702167bffaba93db10932c","78f72dac13eaa006e27325ea3337920233639d7146ca49b423201924502a987e"],"summary_ko":"M073후보2정확적용·궤적순서수치PASS/준비전개부분개선,큰쓸기·독립반동시각FAIL로최종REJECT/HOLD.원본리그실패/관통확정아님.새원저자동작근거전추가수정·재촬영중단,독립boar14진행.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-BOAR14-EXISTING-RIG-MOVE-ATTACK-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-BOAR14-EXISTING-RIG-MOVE-ATTACK-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"e07ed912cdf994616acb8d4b09968453843676f46823909123f515f26ca64d4c","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bd3fc68722e724c41e7367ab91cd0c8b9536c5e2359a00e18018d74f8b0b53b","bbb8878835495f182a1e38fa5384e91d065d59c6372550aab061f54ea879a56b"],"summary_ko":"멧돼지14기존작은게임영상Move교대/엄니Attack읽힘미확정HOLD.원본51본/4weights·55058verts30952faces/ownedMove8Attack6구조확인.원본직접두시점134frame/13exactseek새증거확보,4sole·엄니/주둥이/어깨부위귀속원제작대기.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-C4-J27J28-ONLY-F-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-C4-J27J28-ONLY-F-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"c024e1a53bd2b5ad76ad0d7810f2d5875a413418dedb550b579fd5edeaa706b6","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 원저자F전체본이동 최종REJECT·C4보존·패치없음. 손87정점RAM G5화면에서 새경계늘어짐·핵심가림 발생해 기술검수HOLD,원저자재판정대기. 발·오른엄지 국소PASS보존.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LEFT34_SEMANTIC_CLASSIFIED_DYNAMIC_OWNERSHIP_HOLD_NO_PATCH_THUMB35_PASS_PRESERVED"},"motion":{"status":"FULLCLIPS_OTHERAXES_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-BOAR14-DIRECT-NATIVE-SOURCE-OWNERSHIP-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-BOAR14-DIRECT-NATIVE-SOURCE-OWNERSHIP-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"562eadab240cb87b35e048e37183757349dc728fa4757582e61ad6280e14ce7e","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bd3fc68722e724c41e7367ab91cd0c8b9536c5e2359a00e18018d74f8b0b53b","bbb8878835495f182a1e38fa5384e91d065d59c6372550aab061f54ea879a56b"],"summary_ko":"멧돼지14직접native134검수·8국소source면귀속완료(4sole/긴엄니/부러진끝/주둥이/어깨혹).원본24XYZUV32raw가중치/seam대조일치,실제8nativeweights+기존13pose로104점CPU궤적.이동공격품질/전체접지미승인·patchnull.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-C4-SEAMCLOSED87-G-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-C4-SEAMCLOSED87-G-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"07daea18ed3894b6d01d4f421fbc3315c22e667751c7521ac761c1729037ea0b","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 원저자G87 위치합성 최종REJECT·C4보존·패치없음. 명세130정점 RAM 스킨진단 H4화면 검증 완료, 범위밖·73본 불변, 실제시각 재판정HOLD. 발·오른엄지 국소PASS보존.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LEFT34_SEMANTIC_CLASSIFIED_DYNAMIC_OWNERSHIP_HOLD_NO_PATCH_THUMB35_PASS_PRESERVED"},"motion":{"status":"FULLCLIPS_OTHERAXES_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-BOAR14-8ANCHOR-NUMERIC-REPAIR-DECISION1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-BOAR14-8ANCHOR-NUMERIC-REPAIR-DECISION1.json","report_sha256":"99b4a245f4510ce6156e5b9571a3e8985a0f78a04850f5e3c93e1a48424aa556","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bd3fc68722e724c41e7367ab91cd0c8b9536c5e2359a00e18018d74f8b0b53b","bbb8878835495f182a1e38fa5384e91d065d59c6372550aab061f54ea879a56b"],"summary_ko":"멧돼지14Move대각선4점교대국소허용·엄니하강상승수치확인,큰퍼올림/제동/반동읽힘미달AttackREVISE/HOLD.전체접지/rigskin/game미검증·patchnull.새구별근거전보어재작업중단,기존8점/13seek/134/480/CPU17반복금지.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-C4-ONE-RING130-H-SKINONLY-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-C4-ONE-RING130-H-SKINONLY-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"873e9bec22bac69dc33536d42da3e33267792caf64f82d468faf1eda728472e0","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 H130 가중치이전 최종REJECT·C4보존·패치없음. 새경계 부품귀속은 기존trueREST5뷰 재사용으로12우선면 모두노출확인·원저자귀속검수HOLD. 추가촬영없음·발/오른엄지 국소PASS보존.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LEFT34_SEMANTIC_CLASSIFIED_DYNAMIC_OWNERSHIP_HOLD_NO_PATCH_THUMB35_PASS_PRESERVED"},"motion":{"status":"FULLCLIPS_OTHERAXES_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M100-042-EXISTING-RIG-MOTION-REVIEW1","asset_id":"M100-042","report_url":"https://chan-woo.com/reviews/MONSTER-M100-042-EXISTING-RIG-MOTION-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"956aea222f9aeb86642f089c502d11f984d49b8f6ad63f7e7e1a0e51a59e03ff","reviewed_exact_sha256":"043c7bc3af7b3584f3e937dfe9470c760528245c7cd767dd0178ed2456e63560","summary_ko":"기존 공격읽힘REVISE/HOLD; 원본rig실패미입증,exactpatchnull. 후속native134/드라이버복원0차이; 원저자source6귀속대기.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR073-C4-H130-BOUNDARY-OWNER-PICK1-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR073-C4-H130-BOUNDARY-OWNER-PICK1-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"42253816135b81b2c0610327b189a0601434130233bde1155f78d63e8576e0c1","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0bb668f1ac4eeef3fd03fb69a5fcf2cff39b911fd74b2a50f0c6165f2ffb7dbf"],"summary_ko":"073 경계12면 원저자시각귀속완료(장갑6/비손소매6),H130거절유지. 원래봉합동작정책·정확목표가중치 미확보로 NO_PATCH·해당수정분기HOLD. C4·발/오른엄지국소PASS보존,다음075검수.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LEFT34_SEMANTIC_CLASSIFIED_DYNAMIC_OWNERSHIP_HOLD_NO_PATCH_THUMB35_PASS_PRESERVED"},"motion":{"status":"FULLCLIPS_OTHERAXES_HOLD"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M042-DIRECT-NATIVE-DRIVER-SOURCE6-REVIEW1","asset_id":"M100-042","report_url":"https://chan-woo.com/reviews/MONSTER-M042-DIRECT-NATIVE-DRIVER-SOURCE6-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"35d775e86eba7c352a0c0c1158eb9a7ac9dd94603438bc5f89ad7db2ea7ab8d5","reviewed_exact_sha256":"043c7bc3af7b3584f3e937dfe9470c760528245c7cd767dd0178ed2456e63560","summary_ko":"6국소sourcepoint귀속 인증/driver복원국소PASS; Attack읽힘REVISE-HOLD. 6nativeweights+기존14pose84CPU좌표후속판정대기.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M042-SOURCE6-84TRAJECTORY-FINAL-REPAIR-DECISION1","asset_id":"M100-042","report_url":"https://chan-woo.com/reviews/MONSTER-M042-SOURCE6-84TRAJECTORY-FINAL-REPAIR-DECISION1.json","report_sha256":"0d28888b79292d0ef1556a0298c1de5457c1d848132361c2748252d0af3bd8c1","reviewed_exact_sha256":"043c7bc3af7b3584f3e937dfe9470c760528245c7cd767dd0178ed2456e63560","summary_ko":"앞발들림복귀/가슴대비뿔국소움직임확인, 강한구르기/수평쓸기읽힘REVISE-HOLD. exactpatchnull동결; 다음M041.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M100-041-EXISTING-SOURCE33-SIXCLIP-REVIEW1","asset_id":"M100-041","report_url":"https://chan-woo.com/reviews/MONSTER-M100-041-EXISTING-SOURCE33-SIXCLIP-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"b4947f85c0ae0abaad7e5d531cf139b18e0d265d94bbb03061a38edc81235be1","reviewed_exact_sha256":"00ed69158027e665e6c441f6d8385b0be39954ded13a4d6bb5b139b5e7a1891a","summary_ko":"기존프리뷰 공격흐름국소ALLOW,지지skin전체HOLD. 새지정8exactnative2view에서1.125초뿔주변trianglefan의심이보여원저자재검수준비; patch없음.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR075-NATIVE-FIRST-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR075-NATIVE-FIRST-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"8ae652d6bf92dd9f85ab0efc63e14f648b6bdd76f54383630aa1ad045a48498f","reviewed_exact_sha256":["b9739c050659bda1837336a18773b8c4d63c90c277d678cda6e2d8763235b7d0"],"summary_ko":"075 원저자최종 NO_PATCH/TODO. 원본·6영상 실수령 SHA/전체디코드 확인,174고유프레임 내 명백한늘어짐·파열 미관찰. 숨은접합/import가중치/gameplay/mobile/physics 미검증,전역최종PASS아님.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"NO_CONFIRMED_VISUAL_FAILURE_HIDDEN_IMPORT_DETAILS_TODO"},"motion":{"status":"REVIEWED174FRAMES_NO_GROSS_DEFORMATION_NOT_GLOBAL_PASS"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M041-EXACT8-NATIVE-HORN-ADJACENT-SURFACE-REVIEW1","asset_id":"M100-041","report_url":"https://chan-woo.com/reviews/MONSTER-M041-EXACT8-NATIVE-HORN-ADJACENT-SURFACE-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"09e8f4b621dab60b34bb8e425f4cc5e62d85396a3e7015e32516f45d591bd95a","reviewed_exact_sha256":"00ed69158027e665e6c441f6d8385b0be39954ded13a4d6bb5b139b5e7a1891a","summary_ko":"새exact8뷰 국소skin늘어짐FAIL확인; F306672/F305521/F302851 native9점 최대모서리81.47배. 부위경계UNKNOWN패치null; 원제작41면귀속후속대기.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M041-FAN9-41FACE-OWNER-EXACT-REPAIR-DECISION1","asset_id":"M100-041","report_url":"https://chan-woo.com/reviews/MONSTER-M041-FAN9-41FACE-OWNER-EXACT-REPAIR-DECISION1.json","report_sha256":"532ef3a3269db4410167c9ccb5ec0dff7aa9d1bbc9f06c34e7d18e046f7cba65","reviewed_exact_sha256":"00ed69158027e665e6c441f6d8385b0be39954ded13a4d6bb5b139b5e7a1891a","summary_ko":"M041 Attack 국소skin결함 확정.9점/41면 검증종료; 뿔·두개피부·갈기 정확귀속과 외곽안전경계미인증으로 exact_patch=null/HOLD. 새sourceface별경계인증시에만재개.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR076-NATIVE-FIRST-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR076-NATIVE-FIRST-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"9a14b6e812909981db6aacf55b66d3f9633f651397749fb657d107fdf69c0d2a","reviewed_exact_sha256":["e0967eb7cb6cbf9b2f0b84d35f52fa4da6ffe4c8e6bd21657a1b1a9293e3e4d2"],"summary_ko":"076 원저자최종 손·손목 피부색 삼각형 돌출 국소 시각 FAIL. 원인 매핑 전 NO_PATCH/HOLD. 두 포즈의 source face와 실제 import 가중치 대응 필요. 게임플레이·모바일·물리 UNKNOWN.","independent_review_axes":{"rig":{"status":"LOCAL_VISUAL_FAIL_SOURCE_CAUSAL_MAPPING_HOLD"},"motion":{"status":"WALKING_RUNNING_LOCAL_HAND_WEDGE_FAIL"},"runtime":{"status":"GAMEPLAY_MOBILE_PHYSICS_UNKNOWN"}},"final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-FIVE-ASSET-EXECUTABLE-REPAIR-DELIVERY1","asset_id":"M041/M081/M042/14/M073","report_url":"https://chan-woo.com/reviews/FIVE-ASSET-AUTHOR-DELIVERY-MANIFEST.json","report_sha256":"2fcff8934b0e8d5622a8148d68d3c8d19dae284dbe2638d8ff8481864149cf46","summary_ko":"원제작3공격후보 실제수령·결정적생성일치. native각73/73/146frames완료;시각재검수/실게임대기. M041/M081경계미인증skinpatchnull.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR076-HAND-WEDGE-TRUEIMPORT-SOURCEFACE-FIXTURE1-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR076-HAND-WEDGE-TRUEIMPORT-SOURCEFACE-FIXTURE1-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"cfdde8da1f75b642392841e69f5be9e76716dfa79defd10a553771ebe525c763","reviewed_exact_sha256":["e0967eb7cb6cbf9b2f0b84d35f52fa4da6ffe4c8e6bd21657a1b1a9293e3e4d2"],"summary_ko":"076 원본 손에 허벅지 본 오귀속 원인 확정,별도234정점 weights-only 후보명세. 실제 후보 A/B는 별도기술결과이며 잔여돌출 REVISE/HOLD.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M042-CANDIDATE3-NATIVE-ATTACK-REVIEW1","asset_id":"M100-042","report_url":"https://chan-woo.com/reviews/MONSTER-M042-CANDIDATE3-NATIVE-ATTACK-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"c3210c8ec1c71db004fd8a275ba9cd320fa8d7b211b92997d96cafbbd9880eaa","summary_ko":"C3앞발개선국소허용/수평쓸기FAIL. 원저자머리1채널C4실제적용·native73frames·기존Combat실이동/공격HP95→86/표시이름·대상노출검증. 뿔접촉/품질재검수HOLD.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR076-CANDIDATE1-ACTUAL-AB-RESIDUAL1-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR076-CANDIDATE1-ACTUAL-AB-RESIDUAL1-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"80b5e3a35fc590d90b56576ebd990efe145304cc6c70971e763d1caaac64e9df","reviewed_exact_sha256":["3eaea04cb33f5457537fabfda229893dafb0b499aeb1000024218e741059e033"],"summary_ko":"076 후보1 잔여 손가락 오귀속 검수와 추가69정점 후보2 명세. 원문 보존. 후보2 Running 잔여3면은 별도 재검수 대상, 전체 PASS 아님.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M042-CANDIDATE4-REAL-GAME-CONTACT-REPAIR1","asset_id":"M100-042","report_url":"https://chan-woo.com/reviews/MONSTER-M042-CANDIDATE4-REAL-GAME-CONTACT-REPAIR1.json","report_sha256":"e1260066b02ca1018b387c41b0701248b755bffca5a1af78c5c45c00fc511153","summary_ko":"앞발·복귀 국소허용, 머리비틀림개선, 큰수평쓸기REVISE. 기존합법접근후Tween도착검증으로수정한새측정에서도두인증뿔면접촉분리.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR076-CANDIDATE2-ACTUAL-AB-RESIDUAL1-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR076-CANDIDATE2-ACTUAL-AB-RESIDUAL1-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"6278da082c56ace24d395686b779ff798761d06354a613450081d677794671b5","reviewed_exact_sha256":["3eaea04cb33f5457537fabfda229893dafb0b499aeb1000024218e741059e033"],"summary_ko":"076 후보1 잔여 손가락 오귀속 검수와 추가69정점 후보2 명세. 원문 보존. 후보2 Running 잔여3면은 별도 재검수 대상, 전체 PASS 아님.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR076-CANDIDATE3-ACTUAL-AB1-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR076-CANDIDATE3-ACTUAL-AB1-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"d62e845e22a0d06590deeb037f4e5f680219632c19fcd7ec9f41a99c16661a41","reviewed_exact_sha256":["cba1f48c636b42d4c389a06987ad28ac9072e70421a9f381026b26c8d8c64ffe"],"summary_ko":"076 후보3 지정 Running+X0.1 피부띠 국소PASS 및 Walking+Z0.7 개선유지. 원문 SHA일치 보존. 이후C3격리게임입력 별도완료,전역채택 승인아님.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M073-V2-CANDIDATE4-PHASE-NATIVE-GAME-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M073-V2-CANDIDATE4-PHASE-NATIVE-GAME-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"cb547e8a5ada92427be79b19e362cc5907bae93071bff1c8ff46039d51474215","reviewed_exact_sha256":["cfad64f07aadd62c2bd4aba7289497583e024ff4702273ef8b19f14b399759e7"],"summary_ko":"M073 v2 유황균열 갈퀴악귀 C4 전방 긁기·독립 회수 국소 ALLOW. 실제 기존게임은 피해 확정 후 .576부터 재생하는 연결 검증만 통과. 공격예고·표면접촉·접지·모바일·정본 채택 HOLD. 원저자 원문 무수정.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR076-C3-GAME-SCOPE-CLOSE1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR076-C3-GAME-SCOPE-CLOSE1.json","report_sha256":"1dd29f530ef8be22f53fdac5491c7d353f2fe7f325f31df59ec8f269fad513e3","reviewed_exact_sha256":["cba1f48c636b42d4c389a06987ad28ac9072e70421a9f381026b26c8d8c64ffe"],"summary_ko":"076 C3 손 피부띠 국소 기술단위 종료. 실제 격리게임 입력과 두 정적 화면 검수, 명백한 재발 미관찰. 최종 채택·충돌·접지·모바일 별도.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M041-ISOLATED132-SOURCE-SEMANTIC-BOUNDARY-REPAIR1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M041-ISOLATED132-SOURCE-SEMANTIC-BOUNDARY-REPAIR1.json","report_sha256":"33e6e3c38c0a4e9087c336a1a35bec40b76ae4cbfd1c2defd63c3cd523d8105a","reviewed_exact_sha256":["00ed69158027e665e6c441f6d8385b0be39954ded13a4d6bb5b139b5e7a1891a"],"summary_ko":"M041 새132면 원본인덱스·두 연결영역·외곽94면 확인. 기관귀속 UNKNOWN, 스킨수정 exact_patch=null. 새 온전한 머리 문맥226면 atlas 요구. 원문 무수정.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"MONSTER-M081-V2-SIXPANEL-LAYER-SOURCEFACE-BOUNDARY-REPAIR1","report_url":"/reviews/MONSTER-M081-V2-SIXPANEL-LAYER-SOURCEFACE-BOUNDARY-REPAIR1.json","report_sha256":"0c860f2bc2e034fc5681feca8415c5a08b9d0bb1dd9b69eceeb9a68a2e712a76","reviewed_exact_sha256":["81bb51a69ba9fa4b5b7d10e34d5cdc90a81c5fdc1db51e1e2b72efe211b1ae6e"],"summary_ko":"M081 v2 새6패널 원본면 검사. 미인증8751면 유지, 바깥308/안쪽경계289면 구분. 신규귀속·가중치 승인0, exact_patch=null. 원문 무수정.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR058-GUARD-V5-EXACT-SKIN-SPEC1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR058-GUARD-V5-EXACT-SKIN-SPEC1.json","report_sha256":"4e99d986a3897bb40ce72a7f6becb565fd66c8cb6b0dd053a269b8f7fbfe333e","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0f74de29ba9c2487974e4e023f722847a310e3b99f7f327dbc4679c69d29cabf"],"summary_ko":"058 V5 오른손42정점 원저자 정확기술명세. 별도후보 SHA일치, 실제Ready/Guard A/B실행. 시각최종/회귀/게임 미완료.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false},{"review_id":"CHAR058-GUARD-V5-HAND-CANDIDATE1-ACTUAL-AB1-REVIEW1","report_url":"/reviews/CHAR058-GUARD-V5-HAND-CANDIDATE1-ACTUAL-AB1-REVIEW1.json","report_sha256":"f250eb3fd732f881af874df9f143f8a83ce08477d9731759572bda330f4a5818","reviewed_exact_sha256":["0f74de29ba9c2487974e4e023f722847a310e3b99f7f327dbc4679c69d29cabf"],"summary_ko":"058 V5 별도후보 Ready/Guard4뷰 원저자 국소PASS_WITH_TODO. 정확V5 대비 걷기/달리기24동조건표본에서큰새변형미관찰. 격리실제입력부분확인;미세봉합·최종통합별도.","final_art_rig_motion_runtime_pass":false}],"schema":{"asset_id":"string","sha256":"exact_source_SHA256","author_review_url":"actual_review_reference","decision":"ALLOW|CONDITIONAL|HOLD|UNKNOWN","evidence_files":[],"technical_test_results":[]},"empty_does_not_mean_pass":true,"original_author_evidence_contract_url":"review-evidence-contract.json","required_separate_statuses":["art_status","geometry_status","rig_status","motion_status","runtime_status"],"author_approved_input":{"asset_id":"TEMP_MAP02_COAST_MACRO_TERRAIN_AUTHOR_INPUT01","stage":"INPUT_ART_ONLY","sha256":"7387698307ee61bc90c2a537336e333dc055e939488acc2877218a0ef9e22f14","input_art_status":"INPUT_ART_ALLOW_WITH_TODO","actual_glb":null,"complete_game_map":false,"input_image":"author/coast-input.png","target_image":"author/coast-target.png"}}